Skip to Content


Notice of the Annual Price Threshold Determination

Document Details

Information about this document as published in the Federal Register.

Published Document

This document has been published in the Federal Register. Use the PDF linked in the document sidebar for the official electronic format.

Start Preamble


Minerals Management Service (MMS), Interior.


Notice of annual price threshold determination and annual average oil and gas market price calculations, along with their effects for the Gulf of Mexico royalty relief programs.


This notice provides the official MMS determination of which Gulf of Mexico price thresholds have been exceeded by annual market prices for oil or gas, by lease vintage, for calendar year 2008. This notice also explains in detail how MMS calculates the annual oil and gas prices and applicable price thresholds used to determine whether royalty relief applies in calendar year 2008 for our various deepwater and deep depth royalty relief programs.

Start Further Info


Marshall Rose, Chief, Economics Division at (703) 787-1536.

End Further Info End Preamble Start Supplemental Information


By various laws (Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act, Deep Water Royalty Relief Act, Energy Policy Act) and regulations (30 CFR 203.48, 203.54, 203.78, 260.110, and 260.122), MMS has authority to impose price thresholds at which otherwise applicable royalty relief is suspended. As prescribed in applicable regulations or lease terms, notwithstanding any provisions for royalty relief, companies are required to pay royalties for those calendar years when annual average New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) market prices for oil or gas exceed the adjusted price thresholds levels. Production generated royalty-free counts against the remaining royalty suspension volume, with one exception. That exception involves deep-gas production from March 1, 2004, through May 2, 2004, from deep wells that qualified for royalty suspension under 30 CFR 203.40 through 203.48 (see 69 FR 24055). As a courtesy, MMS tracks, calculates, and posts on its Web site a variety of relevant information about applicable oil and gas prices and the price threshold levels to be used in determining whether a particular lease continues to be eligible for deep gas, deep water, or other royalty relief. The information contained in this published Start Printed Page 26880notice was previously posted on the MMS Web site. Beginning in the second quarter of each year, the MMS will estimate the average market price at which oil or gas would have to sell during the remainder of the calendar year for the estimated price threshold to be exceeded for that year.

The following table represents the official MMS price threshold and market price calculation determinations made for calendar year 2008. Any subsequent inflation adjustments or market price adjustments will not affect these official results or their implication for royalty relief on the designated categories of leases.

Applicable Price Thresholds and Market Prices for Calendar Year 2008

ProductLease vintage (sale held in)Annual average NYMEX price ($/bbl or $/MMBtu)Adjusted price threshold level ($/bbl or $/MMBtu)Royalty relief suspended
Deepwater oilBefore 1996; 1996-1997 1; 20001; 2002-3/2004; 2007-200899.7437.18Yes.
Deepwater oil200199.7433.33Yes.
Deepwater oil8/2004-200699.7443.28Yes.
Deepwater gasBefore 1996; 1996-1997 1; 20001; 2002-3/2004; 2007-20088.894.65Yes.
Deepwater gas20018.894.17Yes.
Deepwater gas8/2004-20068.897.21Yes.
Deep gas3/2001 28.894.17Yes.
Deep gas8/2001-2003 28.895.95Yes.
Deep gas 3Before 2001, 2001-2003 2, 2004-20088.8910.37No.
Deep gas 4Before 2001, 2001-2003 2, 2004-20088.8910.37 and 4.65No 4.
Deep gas 5All years8.894.65Yes.
bbl = barrel, MMBtu = million British Thermal Units, bcf = billion cubic feet.
1 Price thresholds do not apply to leases issued in deepwater during the years 1998-1999 due to an administrative oversight. If the Kerr-McGee v. DOI, Fifth Circuit Court Decision (1/12/09) is upheld, price thresholds will not apply to deepwater leases issued during the years 1996-2000.
2 Leases issued in water 0-200 meters deep during 2001-2003 had the option to convert from lower price thresholds under lease terms to higher price thresholds set forth in the regulations.
3 Applies to qualified deep wells on leases in water 0-200 meters deep that spudded after 3/26/2003 and produced before 5/3/2009, and to qualified ultra-deep wells on leases in water 0-200 meters deep that spudded between 3/26/2003 and 5/17/2007 and produced before 5/3/2009.
4 Applies to qualified ultra-deep wells on leases in water 0-200 meters deep that spudded on or after 5/18/2007 and produced before 5/03/09. The higher price threshold applies to the first 25 bcf of royalty relief; the lower price threshold applies to the next 10 bcf of royalty relief. For qualified ultra-deep wells on leases in water 0-200 meters deep that spudded on or after 5/3/2009, the lower price threshold applies to the entire 35 bcf of royalty relief.
5 Applies to qualified deep wells on leases in water 200-400 meters deep that spudded on or after 5/18/2007 and produced before 5/3/2013, and to qualified ultra-deep wells on leases in water 200-400 meters deep that spudded on or after 5/18/2007.

Technical Documentation

The data and methodology used for making the 2008 calculations and determinations are discussed below. This same information for all years since 1996 is available at the Economics Division Web site​econ/​econpt.htm. Additional information and notes about understanding this Web site are included at the end of this notice.

Methodology for Calculation of the Actual Annual Average NYMEX Nearby Delivery Price

1. We use the price for the nearby delivery month or front month. That is, the price for the first contract or earliest month that you can get the delivery/ inventory for buying and selling today's product. For example, on October 1, 2007, the nearby delivery month was November 2007. There are prices for other delivery months that can be bought and sold on October 1, 2007, such as December 2007, January 2008, etc., but the “nearby delivery month” would be November 2007. However, the nearby delivery month is not always the next month because the last trading day of the month differs for oil and gas futures. For example, on March 27, 2008, the nearby delivery month for light sweet crude oil is May 2008 while for natural gas it is still April 2008.

2. The daily NYMEX closing price is listed as the settle price at the end of business trading hours for each commodity. These are listed at and also summarized at

3. The daily closing average is used to calculate the monthly average. For holidays and weekends, we use the previous business day's closing average. For example, Table A illustrates the calculation of the average NYMEX oil price for the month of December 2008 (Note—this methodology is different from the Minerals Revenue Management's Royalty In-Kind Program that excludes weekends and holidays). Our analysis indicates that inclusion or exclusion of weekends and holidays does not bias the annual average price calculation in either direction. We chose to include the weekends and holidays, as highlighted in Table A, to avoid the necessity to keep track of actual trading days each month all year, and because our source summarizes the monthly price data with the inclusion.

 Table A—Example of Monthly Average Price Calculation

DayDateDaily closing price ($/bbl)
Start Printed Page 26881
Thursday (Holiday)12/25/200835.35

4. The monthly average is used to calculate the annual average. For example, Table B illustrates the calculation of the NYMEX oil price for 2008. The calculation for the year-to-date average consists of the monthly averages so far in the year. The dollar amount of the result is rounded to the nearest hundredth decimal point (i.e., cents). We do not weight the average each month by the number of days in that month, again to avoid adding superfluous complexity.

Table B—Example of Annual Average Price Calculation

MonthAverage closing price ($/bbl)

Methodology for Calculation of the Applicable Oil and Natural Gas Price Thresholds

1. The price thresholds are estimates until they are locked-in for a calendar year based on the most current inflation data available after the close of the year. In conjunction with the calculation of the annual market prices for oil and gas above, once the price thresholds are locked in, MMS makes an official determination regarding whether these market prices have exceeded the applicable price thresholds for the calendar year for a given vintage of lease and royalty relief program. After this official MMS determination is made, any subsequent revisions in the underlying source of the inflation figures will not affect the locked-in price thresholds or the determination of eligibility for royalty relief for that calendar year.

2. The source for inflation data is the Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) The U.S. Economic Accounts—Gross Domestic Product (GDP), National Income and Products Account (NIPA) Table 1.1.9. The 4th quarter implicit price deflator is not available from BEA until late March of the subsequent calendar year.

3. The implicit price deflator for GDP is used to calculate the applicable annual inflation rate, as illustrated in Table C. The deflator from the applicable year is divided by the deflator from the previous year and subtracted by one. For example, the inflation rate used to set the 2008 price threshold is calculated as {(122.42/119.82) − 1 = 2.2%}. Start Printed Page 26882

Table C—Inflation Rates (Current and Locked-In)

[Derived from BEA data]

Calendar yearImplicit price deflator for GDP (base = 1996)Implicit price deflator for GDP (base = 2000)Current annual inflation rateLocked-in annual inflation rate

4. Because price thresholds are fixed for previous years, the current inflation rate displayed on the BEA Web site (see Table C above) may not correspond precisely to the rate MMS employed to calculate previous price thresholds. For example, the GDP deflator posted on the BEA Web site in March 2008 shows an inflation rate for 2004 of 2.9 percent. However, back in March 2005, when the 2004 price threshold was locked in, the BEA Web site showed an inflation rate of 2.1 percent, which MMS used in a change for the deepwater oil price threshold for most leases, as shown in the first column of the Deepwater Table on the Web site, from $32.81/bbl in 2003 to $33.50/bbl in 2004. The figures that were shown on the BEA Web site in March of each year were used to make the adjustments in the price thresholds from year to year. Rounding explains any remaining small differences between calculated locked-in inflation rates and those rates depicted on the MMS Web site. Therefore, to replicate the calculation for previous price thresholds, use the locked-in inflation rate. To replicate the calculation for the estimated price threshold, prior to March of the subsequent year, use the current inflation rate.

Start Signature

Dated: April 20, 2009.

Chris C. Oynes,

Associate Director for Offshore Energy and Minerals Management.

End Signature End Supplemental Information

[FR Doc. E9-13094 Filed 6-3-09; 8:45 am]